The Music Journal
Friday March 19 - Her name is Aphrodite and she rides a crimson shell
I decided today that I wanted to learn a bit more about the classic 60s band Cream, following on from hearing a bit of them both in classes and from my dad's record collections.
Of course, to learn more about an artist and their music in the modern world meant I opened up peer-to-peer file sharing program Kazaa and had a quick search for some notable tracks. I had no problem donwloading a copy of Tales Of Brave Ulysses or Strange Brew, but when it came time to listen to White Room I got about a minute into the song and the soothing sounds of Eric Clapton's guitar were replaced with high pitched very irritating beeps that actually caused some significant pain as I was wearing headphones at the time. Unfortunately for me I had stumbled across one of many fake files deliberately swamped onto Kazaa by companies to deter the download of files. The first part of a hoax song sounds exactly like the original so upon preview they're indistinguishable; it's not until the user has spent their time waiting for the track to download completely and listens to it that it becomes apparent the file isn't what they were looking for.
This has become a widespread practice, according to a quick search on Google. The most notable mass-flooding of fake tracks to catch pirates was prior to the release of Madonna's "American Life" album last year: the BBC reported on April 22 2003 that-
File-sharing networks have been flooded with fake tracks, which contain no music but instead have Madonna saying; "What the f*** do you think you are doing?
The pirates quickly hit back however. Madonna's site was hacked days later with a particularly smart-arse reply to her original question; and those more musically inclined simply remixed her outburst into hilarious parody songs.
Where do I stand on the mp3 issue? Although I know it's wrong, and technically stealing, I'll continue to use file-sharing programs until a better solution is found. For me Kazaa is a tool not unlike the radio - a chance to sample tracks and if you like, follow up your favourites. A brief examination of my music collection reveals this to be a fairly true statement. Looking at my more recent purchases:
Audioslave - Audioslave: Bought after sampling and enjoying 'Cochise'
Beck - Seachange: Bought after downloading 'Golden Years' and also borrowing other friends' Beck CDs
Mogwai - Young Team: Bought following sampling a track called 'Summer'
George - Polyserena: Bought after downloading 'Chemical Dreams'
Bluebottle Kiss - Come Across: Bought after hearing single 'Everything Begins And Ends At Exactly The Right Time' on the radio, which I then sought out on the band's website and ended up downloading some of their music from there
Supergrass - Life On Other Planets: Bought after seeing it for a very cheap price, then downloading and enjoying 'Grace'.
While I still buy some albums without hearing anything first (The Flaming Lips' Yoshimi Battles The Pink Robots and the self-titled album by The Dissociatives are recent examples) I doubt if I would have bought any of the above CDs without first having heard a track. I also like the idea of keeping and having a collection of my favourite music: the physicality of handing over money to buy a CD, and reading the liner notes while listening to it is still a great part of the experience for me. Of course, this reason doesn't excuse the many drawbacks of the system - there are still many people who download entire albums, robbing artists of any royalties completely: not to mention the fact that there are quality issues with encoded music, and time issues involved with waiting for downloads to reach your computer. I like the idea of pay-for-download schemes like iTunes, but until their catalogue reaches songs I actually want to hear they're simply not an option - and even at that point, $1.99 to hear one song might be a little too expensive.
It must be admitted I have a vested interest in this issue however - I own a portable Creative mp3 player at the moment, and have had an mp3 player in some form since 2001. I encode most of my own legal CDs onto my computer hard drive and listen to all my songs that way. It's much easier to carry 50 songs in my pocket instead of dragging CDs around everywhere; the convenience of the mp3 format is undeniable.
I don't think there's an easy solution to the piracy problem. The internet has cultivated a "something for nothing, information should be free" line of thinking that will be extremely hard to erase. I'm quite happy to keep buying CDs from stores, but I also value being able to listen to bits of them first with relatively no hassle whatsoever.